Skip to main content

Minimal Surfaces : Trefoil Knot

Minimal Surfaces : Trefoil Knot

A minimal surface is the surface with minimal area for a given perimeter. As such, what is the minimal surface of a perimeter is am easy question with a hard answer. More formally, a surface, \(S\), is minimal if and only if for every point of \(S\) has a neighborhood bounded by a simple closed curve which has the least area among all surfaces with the same boundary. Soap bubbles are often used when discussing minimal surfaces because the soap naturally creates a minimal surface given a perimeter—note, an actual soap bubble that is a sphere is not a minimal surface as it does not have a boundary perimeter. As simple minimal surface to begin thinking about is the catenoid, shown below.

The curved surface of the catenoid represents the minimal surface for our given perimeter—i.e. the two circles at the top and bottom. If you think back to the last time you played with bubbles, you might remember seeing either this shape or other similar ones. See the image below to see that soap bubbles will in fact form the catenoid as the minimal surface between two perimeter circles.

There are a number of ways to formally define what a minimal surface is, one of which we touched upon earlier. Now, however, I am going to give what I feel is a more useful, but perhaps less intuitive, definition for a minimal surface:

We will define curvature by \[ \kappa = \frac{ \| \vec{T} '(t) \| }{ \| \vec{r} '(t) \|} \] where \( \kappa\) is curvature, \(\vec{r} (t)\) is the parameterization of a curve, and \(\vec{T} (t)\) is the unit tangent vector to \(\vec{r} (t)\). For a surface \(M\) in \( ℝ^3 \), there is a tangent plane at each point. Every point on \(M\) has a normal vector perpendicular to the tangent plane. Intersect any plane containing the normal vector with the surface in order to get a curve, defined by \(f(x)\). Note that the average of the curve defined by \(f(x)\) over \([a,b]\) is \[ \frac{1}{b-a} \int^{b}_{a} f(x) dx. \] As we rotate the plane always containing the normal vector by the angle \(\theta\) the curvature varies so we must compute the mean curvature of the surface \(M\) at point \(p\) as follows \[ \frac{1}{2\pi} \int^{2\pi}_{0} \kappa(\theta) d\theta. \] The surface is a minimal surface if and only if the mean curvature at of every point \(p\) on the surface \(M\) is zero (0).

Following the general theme of this course we will be creating a 3D example; but how does one model a minimal surface in three dimensions? As previously stated, minimal surfaces are easy questions with hard answers, and also previously stated, soap bubbles will naturally create a minimal surface given a perimeter. So, we will be creating a perimeter, which will be called a frame when referring to the actual 3D model, that we can dip into soap bubble solution and then watch the soap bubbles form the minimal surfaces. This allows us to ask the easy question of what will our minimal surface be and get the tool of the bubble solution to do the hard work of answering the question for us.

As you will be able to tell from the title of this post, I will be attempting to determine what the minimal surface of a trefoil knot is via our frame and bubbles. An image of the frame I will be 3D printing can be found below, note this frame will be approximately 2 inches square when printed.

I was originally concerned that using a trefoil knot would be seen as repetitive, especially considering our next topic is also knots, but I decided that the surface the trefoil knot and its frame would produce were too interesting to pass up. The minimal surface formed will not be too revolutionary in all but one aspect. The simple aspect of the surface is that it will be a fairly average smooth surface with the exception being that it will intersect itself. Since a knot "passes through" itself so will the minimal surface. I find the terribly interesting as some of the points \(p\) on our surface \(M\) will have two normal vectors at the points of intersection, and those normal vectors will have two tangents vectors that are equal, and are the same vector in actuality. All while the mean curvature at these points \(p\) is zero.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Do Over: Integration Over a Region in a Plane

Throughout the semester we have covered a variety of topics and how their mathematical orientation applies to real world scenarios. One topic we discussed, and I would like to revisit, is integration over a region in a plane which involves calculating a double integral. Integrating functions of two variables allows us to calculate the volume under the function in a 3D space. You can see a more in depth description and my previous example in my blog post, https://ukyma391.blogspot.com/2021/09/integration-for-over-regions-in-plane_27.html . I want to revisit this topic because in my previous attempt my volume calculations were incorrect, and my print lacked structural stability. I believed this print and calculation was the topic I could most improve on and wanted to give it another chance. What needed Improvement? The function used previously was f(x) = cos(xy) bounded on [-3,3] x [-1,3]. After solving for the estimated and actual volume, it was difficult to represent in a print...
Post a Comment
Read more

Minimal Surfaces

Minimum surfaces can be described in many equivalent ways. Today, we are going to focus on minimum surfaces by defining it using curvature. A surface is a minimum surface if and only if the mean curvature at every point is zero. This means that every point on the surface is a saddle point with equal and opposite curvature allowing the smallest surface area possible to form. Curvature helps define a minimal surface by looking at the normal vector. For a surface in R 3 , there is a tangent plane at each point. At each point in the surface, there is a normal vector perpendicular to the tangent plane. Then, we can intersect any plane that contains the normal vector with the surface to get a curve. Therefore, the mean curvature of a surface is defined by the following equation. Where theta is an angle from a starting plane that contains the normal vector. For this week’s project, we will be demonstrating minimum surfaces with a frame and soap bubbles! How It Works Minimum surfac...
Post a Comment
Read more

Do Over: Ruled Surfaces

Why to choose this project to repeat For the do over project, I would like to choose the ruled surfaces. I don't think my last project was creative, and the 3D printed effect was not very satisfactory. In the previous attempts, all the lines are connected between a straight line and a circle. This connection structure is relatively uncomplicated. The printed model has too many lines, resulting in too dense line arrangement. The gaps between lines are too small, and the final effect is that all the lines are connected into a curved surface, which is far from the effect I expected. What to be improved In this do over project, I would like to improve in two aspects. Firstly, a different ruled surface is chosen. In the previous model, one curve is a unit circle on the \(x-y\) plane, and the ruled surface is a right circular conoid. In this do over project, it is replaced by two border lines. Each borderline is in the shape of an isosceles right triangl...
Post a Comment
Read more