Skip to main content

An Assortment of Minimal Surfaces

 In the most basic sense, a minimal surface is one that can locally minimize its surface area. Such a surface has a mean curvature of zero! Curvature is how much a surface, or parameterized curve changes at each point. Consider the sine curve. Intuitively it can be understood that it is "curvier" than a line, or even a parabola. Mean curvature is the average of the sum of curvature at each point. 

Rigorously parameterizing a minimal surface poses a formidable challenge, and a relatively small amount of these surfaces have been discovered. The simplest, but most redundant example is the plane. It has no curvature at any point, so of course it has a mean curvature of zero across the whole surface!

Shown below is a helicoid that encloses a soap film. This was taken from user "Blinking Spirit" on Wikipedia. The soap film forms a minimal surface defined between the helicoid. The reason for this is described later on.


 

The parameterized minimal surfaces take on exotic forms since they must fit such strict criteria. The criteria that they must have a mean curvature of zero is just one of several criteria that a minimal surface must meet. The helicoid is a familiar example of a minimal surface. A famous, but exotic looking example is the saddle tower. Wikipedia user "Anders Sandberg" created the image below of the saddle tower. Despite its odd shape, it has a mean curvature of zero!

As stated above, a soap film can form a minimal surface between two arbitrary curves. This should not be surprising though, because the soap film must achieve the lowest possible energy between the two curves. The energy of the film is the product of the tension the surface experiences and the surface area. To survive as film, it must decrease the surface area as much as possible because tension will more or less stay constant. In doing so, it achieves the lowest possible potential energy, which allows it to persist as a film. 

So despite rigorously parameterizing a minimal surface, they can be easily be created in a physical sense through creating a soap film between two completely arbitrary curves! To illustrate this, I created the following objects.

In a simple example, I created two non-concentric circles of variable radii, shown below. 


The lower circle has a diameter of 3 inches when printed at an appropriate scale while the upper circle has a diameter of 2 inches. They are held together by a cylinder which has a height of roughly 6 inches. This will not only hold the circles together, but allow for them to be dipped in the soap solution. The soap film will extend from the bottom curve to the top. However, if the potential energy of the surface is too high, then it will break and instead form inside each respective curve rather than between them!

My second object aims to prove that a soap film can create a minimal surface between two completely arbitrary curves. I once again created two non-concentric circles but this time made their height vary by the product of sine and cosine. Their radii are 1.5 inches when printed at scale and 1.2 inches respectively and the cylinder between them will have a height of 6 inches. 

My last object aims to facetiously reproduce a result described in a review of the computational study of organic semiconductors by Coropceanu et al. in 2007 from their work Charge Transport in Organic Semiconductors. They showed that the transfer integral (how well molecular orbitals overlap to facilitate charge transfer) decreases as two cofacial tetracene molecules move away from each other in space. We know that the soap film has less likelihood of surviving as two curves move apart, so obviously, this is a very good representation of the transfer integral, with no false equivalencies whatsoever. 




Likewise, the transfer integral is variable as two cofacial tetracene molecules slide past each other in space, while at a fixed horizontal distance between each other. Once again, this is definitely best modeled through soap! What else could do this?

My object, which is definitely suitable for publication in Materials Horizons, is shown below. The real length of the object is 6 inches, but will be scaled down to 3 inches. The fused hexagons are 2 inches apart, and the cylinder which holds them together will have a scaled height of roughly 4 inches.







































For the 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Do Over: Integration Over a Region in a Plane

Throughout the semester we have covered a variety of topics and how their mathematical orientation applies to real world scenarios. One topic we discussed, and I would like to revisit, is integration over a region in a plane which involves calculating a double integral. Integrating functions of two variables allows us to calculate the volume under the function in a 3D space. You can see a more in depth description and my previous example in my blog post, https://ukyma391.blogspot.com/2021/09/integration-for-over-regions-in-plane_27.html . I want to revisit this topic because in my previous attempt my volume calculations were incorrect, and my print lacked structural stability. I believed this print and calculation was the topic I could most improve on and wanted to give it another chance. What needed Improvement? The function used previously was f(x) = cos(xy) bounded on [-3,3] x [-1,3]. After solving for the estimated and actual volume, it was difficult to represent in a print...

Minimal Surfaces

Minimum surfaces can be described in many equivalent ways. Today, we are going to focus on minimum surfaces by defining it using curvature. A surface is a minimum surface if and only if the mean curvature at every point is zero. This means that every point on the surface is a saddle point with equal and opposite curvature allowing the smallest surface area possible to form. Curvature helps define a minimal surface by looking at the normal vector. For a surface in R 3 , there is a tangent plane at each point. At each point in the surface, there is a normal vector perpendicular to the tangent plane. Then, we can intersect any plane that contains the normal vector with the surface to get a curve. Therefore, the mean curvature of a surface is defined by the following equation. Where theta is an angle from a starting plane that contains the normal vector. For this week’s project, we will be demonstrating minimum surfaces with a frame and soap bubbles! How It Works Minimum surfac...

Do Over: Ruled Surfaces

Why to choose this project to repeat For the do over project, I would like to choose the ruled surfaces. I don't think my last project was creative, and the 3D printed effect was not very satisfactory. In the previous attempts, all the lines are connected between a straight line and a circle. This connection structure is relatively uncomplicated. The printed model has too many lines, resulting in too dense line arrangement. The gaps between lines are too small, and the final effect is that all the lines are connected into a curved surface, which is far from the effect I expected. What to be improved In this do over project, I would like to improve in two aspects. Firstly, a different ruled surface is chosen. In the previous model, one curve is a unit circle on the \(x-y\) plane, and the ruled surface is a right circular conoid. In this do over project, it is replaced by two border lines. Each borderline is in the shape of an isosceles right triangl...