Skip to main content

Ambiguous Cylinder Illusion

How the ambiguous object works

In arts and entertainment, optical illusions have been used to create the impression of impossibility. In 2016, Professor Kokichi Sugihara in Japan found ambiguous cylinders that appear drastically different when viewed from two specific viewpoints. Suppose we have two viewers looking down on a curve floating above the \(xy-\)plane. The first viewer is a person looking at the curve, and the second viewer is in the mirror. We would like the two viewers to look down on the curve at 45-degree angles on opposite sides of the \(xy-\)plane. From the viewers’ perspectives, it looks as if they are viewing the curves and respectively, as shown in the following picture.
(https://m-repo.lib.meiji.ac.jp/dspace/bitstream/10291/19877/1/jma_12_1_2.pdf)

The key to the ambiguous cylinder is that the top of the cylinder is not a planar curve. This can be explained by the natural assumption of human visual perception. Natural assumption regard in visual depth three-dimensional object has width, height, and depth. As we know, two-dimensional figures don't have information on depth. But humans have the capacity to perceive a two-dimensional figure as a three-dimensional object. That's because our natural assumptions subconsciously add information on depth. When we see an illustration of an "impossible" object, we subconsciously try to perceive the object based on our natural assumptions.

Our design of an ambiguous cylinder

Our design consists of a curve of two diamonds and a curve of a circle. The curve of two diamonds is defined as following:
Upper part: \[y=\left\{\begin{split} \begin{aligned} &1+x, &-1 &\le x \lt -0.5 \\ &-x, &-0.5 &\le x \lt 0\\ &x, &0 &\le x \lt 0.5 \\ &1-x, &0.5 &\le x \le 1\\ \end{aligned} \end{split}\right.\] Lower part: \[y=\left\{\begin{split} \begin{aligned} &-1-x, &-1 &\le x \lt -0.5 \\ &x, &-0.5 &\le x \lt 0\\ &-x, &0 &\le x \lt 0.5 \\ &-1+x, &0.5 &\le x \le 1\\ \end{aligned} \end{split}\right.\]
The curve of a unit circle is defined as following: \[x^2+y^2=1\]
We design a cylinder with OpenSCAD to show these two different curves. From the viewers’ perspectives, it looks as if they are viewing two curves respectively. The design looks like a vertical cylinder, but its section appears to be different; in one view it appears to be two diamonds, while in the other view it appears to a circle.

Why to use this design

  1. The two curves in this design are different enough to show the ambiguous cylinder illusion. Our design looks like a circular cylinder from the front and a two-diamond cylinder in the mirror. It is a magic phenomenon. The direct views of the objects and their mirror images generate quite different interpretations of the 3D shapes. We cannot correct our interpretations although we logically know that they come from the same objects. Even if the object is rotated in front of a viewer, it is difficult to understand the true shape of the object, and thus the illusion does not disappear.
  2. The unusual visual effects of ambiguous cylinder illusion might be useful. At least upon one's first encounter with ambiguous cylinders, they are surprising and mysterious. Optical illusions including ambiguous cylinders are potential resources for new products in many fields such as education, architecture, art, entertainment, advertising, and tourism. In the above design, we investigate the magic phenomenon of ambiguous cylinder illusion. This helps us to better understand the process of human visual perception.
In the above design, we investigate the magic phenomenon of ambiguous cylinder illusion. This helps us to better understand the process of human visual perception.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Do Over: Double Integrals over Regions

Introduction Over the semester we've looked at many topics and created 3D models. For this we are going to revisit an old topic, double integrals over a region. In this we found the volume of a surface in the xyz-plane bounded by two curves. From the many topics I chose to revisit this topic. I have a couple reason to why I chose to redo this. First, the model did not print correctly. The print added spaces between the rectangular prisms. Another reason was that I think the surface and curves did not represent the topic entirely. The surface I chose just increased between the curves. Improvements When making the model on Onshape there were no spaces between the rectangles, which can be seen on the right. However, when printing this spaces were being added. The second issue was with the surface I chose which was \(f(x,y)=xy+x\). This function only increased over the two curves I chose \begin{align*} f(x) &= \sqrt{x} ...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Septoil Knot

Knots are a very interesting topic and a field that has not quite been fully discovered, so mathematicians are still discovering new ideas and invariances about knots even today. While it may seem like knots are a simple skill you learn at camp, they actually have a lot of mathematical properties and in this blog post we are going to look at just a few. By mathematical definition, a knot is a closed curve in three dimensional space that does not intersect itself. Since we are working with three dimensional space and you are reading this on a two dimensional screen, we need a way to look at knots in two dimensions and that is where knot projections come in. A knot projection is simply a picture of a knot in two dimensions and where a knot crosses itself in the projection is simply a crossing of that projection. The number of crossings of a knot is the smallest number of crossings among all projections of a knot. Since a knot is not necessarily solid, one...
Post a Comment
Read more

Knot 10-84

Introduction In mathematics, a knot is simply a closed loop. The simplest version of this is the unknot, which is a just a closed circle (imagine a ponytail holder). Knots, however, quickly become more complicated than this more basic example. This post will examine a particular knot (knot 10-84) and a few of its knot invariants. Crossing Number Knots are often defined by their crossing number, which is the number of times the knot’s strands cross each other. As indicated in its name, knot 10-84 is a 10 crossing knot. In order to visualize the knot, we can look at its knot projection, in which the knot is represented by a line segment broken only at its undercrossings: Tricolorability Now that we’ve looked at knot crossings, we will examine a potential property of knots: tricolorability. In order to understand tricolorability, it is first important to know that one strand of a knot is defined as an unbroken line segment in the knot p...
Post a Comment
Read more