Skip to main content

Solids of Revolution: The Washer Method

 

Introduction

Imagine for a moment that you work for a chocolate factory and help to create new treats. You’re very good at your job and have developed a design for a new candy consisting of a chocolate shell with a caramel-filled cavity. You want the outside of the shell to be 1.5 inches tall and have the same curve as the equation \( f(x)=- \frac{1}{9}\ x^2+ \frac{3}{4}\ \). You also need there to be an opening in the center for the filling, which you want to have the same curve as \( g(x)= \frac{1}{2}\ - \frac{1}{2}\ e^{-x} \). There’s only one problem: before you can begin manufacturing your masterpiece, your boss wants to know what the volume of this candy is so he can order the correct amount of chocolate. Is there a way to calculate the volume of such a complicated shape? Fortunately, there is, with a little help from calculus.

What is the Washer Method?

As discussed above, we know the wall of our solid will consist of the space between the following two curves. Since it must be 1.5 inches tall, we will only look at the interval \( 0 \leq x \leq 1.5 \):

Imagine rotating the area between these curves around the x-axis – that would give us the solid we are trying to create! The washer method is a way to calculate the volume of such a solid by dividing it into disks (or washers in this case, since there is a hole in the middle) and adding up the volumes of those disks. First we'll use the washer method to get an estimate of our shape’s volume by dividing our solid into 10 washers. Since our interval is 1.5 inches long, this means that each washer will have the following height: \[ h=1.5 \div 10=0.15 \ \textrm{inches} \]

For our first washer, we start at \( x=0 \). At this point, the distance from the center to the outer wall (in other words, the outer radius) is: \( f(x)=- \frac{1}{9}\ (0)^2+ \frac{3}{4}\ = \frac{3}{4}\ \) inches wide. Similarly, the hole at the center has a radius of \( g(x)= \frac{1}{2}\ - \frac{1}{2}\ e^0=0 \) inches. This means our first washer is a disk of radius 0.75 inches with a hole of radius 0 inches. This is a cylinder we can easily compute the volume of: \[ V_1=( \pi (0.75)^2 \cdot 0.15)-( \pi (0)^2 \cdot 0.15)=0.265 \ \textrm{in}^2 \]

That’s one washer done. By following the same steps, we can compute the volume for all 10 washers along our interval:

By creating these washers, we’ve developed an approximation of our solid that looks like the model below. The model is 1.5 inches tall at its tallest point and 1.5 inches wide at its widest point:

Now we can simply add these up to get the total volume! Doing this, we get \( 1.898 \ \textrm{inches}^2 \). Remember, however, that this is not the exact volume because the edges of the solid above are not smooth exacltly like our equations- it is an approximation.

Applying the Washer Method

So far, we have an estimate of our solid’s volume. We know that the more washers we use to calculate the volume, the more accurate our calculations will be since they will follow the curve of our equations more closely. As you know, integrating a function over an interval is like adding an infinite number of rectangles to calculate the area beneath the function. Thus, we can do the same thing for our solid by using integration in our equation for the volume of a washer.

Therefore, the equation we used earlier to calculate the volume of one washer \[ V= \pi R^2h- \pi r^2h= \pi h(R^2-r^2) \] becomes \[ V= \pi \int_{a}^{b} (R^2-r^2) \,dx \] where \( R \) represents the radius for the outer edge and \( r \) represents the radius for the inner cavity on the interval \( a \leq x \leq b \) .

Using this equation on our example from before, we get the following integral: \[ \pi \int_{0}^{1.5} (f(x)^2-g(x)^2) \,dx = \pi \int_{0}^{1.5} \Big( (- \frac{1}{9}\ x^2+ \frac{3}{4}\ )^2-( \frac{1}{2}\ - \frac{1}{2}\ e^{-x})^2 \Big) \,dx \] All that’s left to do is evaluate the integral. \[ \pi \int_{0}^{1.5} \Big( \frac{1}{81}\ x^3- \frac{1}{6}\ x^2+ \frac{9}{16}\ -( \frac{1}{4}\ - \frac{1}{2}\ e^{-x}+ \frac{1}{4}\ e^{-2x}) \Big) \,dx \] \[ = \pi \int_{0}^{1.5} \Big( \frac{1}{81}\ x^3- \frac{1}{6}\ x^2+ \frac{5}{16}\ + \frac{1}{2}\ e^{-x}- \frac{1}{4}\ e^{-2x} \Big) \,dx \] \[ \pi \Big[ \frac{1}{405}\ x^4- \frac{1}{18}\ x^3+ \frac{5}{16}\ x- \frac{1}{2}\ e^{-x}+ \frac{1}{8}\ e^{-2x} \Big] \] \[ \pi \bigg[ \frac{(1.5)^4}{405}\ - \frac{(1.5)^3}{18}\ + \frac{5(1.5)}{16}\ - \frac{1}{2}\ e^{-1.5}+ \frac{1}{8}\ e^{-3}- \Big( \frac{0^4}{405}\ - \frac{0^3}{18}\ + \frac{5(0)}{16}\ - \frac{1}{2}\ e^0+ \frac{1}{8}\ e^0 \Big) \bigg] \] \[ =1.7896 \]

Therefore, we have determined that the volume of our solid is \( 1.7896 \ \textrm{in}^2 \) and can tell our boss exactly what volume of chocolate we need to make our candy.

Why These Functions?

The functions used in the preceding example were chosen for three primary reasons. The first and most salient of these reasons is the functions have interesting behavior that reinforces the learner’s understanding of the material. Compared to linear functions, the curving path of these functions allow the learner to observe the relationship between the functions and the changing widths of the washers on both the inside and outside of the model. Furthermore, both of the functions have steeper slopes at some point along the integral (for \( f(x) \) this increases with \( x \) and for \( g(x) \) this decreases with \( x \) ) which allows the learner to observe the relationship between the slope and the changes in the sizes of the washers. Secondly, these functions together produce a shape that students could reasonably imagine being a chocolate candy. This makes the material more approachable by providing a model of something that could (with a little imagination) serve a real-world purpose. Lastly, these functions result in an equation that is easy to integrate, making the example accessible to students who don’t remember (or struggled with) more advanced integration techniques. Thus, the example uses math that is not trivial while still keeping the focus on the new method.

Author: Sarah Bombrys

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Approximation of a Solid of Revolution

Most math teachers I've had have been able to break down Calculus into two very broad categories: derivatives and integrals. What is truly amazing, is how much you can do with these two tools. By using integration, it is possible to approximate the shape of a 2-D function that is rotated around an axis. This solid created from the rotation is known as a solid of revolution. To explain this concept, we will take a look at the region bounded by the two functions: \[ f(x) = 2^{.25x} - 1 \] and \[ g(x) = e^{.25x} - 1 \] bounded at the line y = 1. This region is meant to represent a cross section of a small bowl. While it may not perfectly represent this practical object, the approximation will be quite textured, and will provide insight into how the process works. The region bounded by the two functions can be rotated around the y-axis to create a fully solid object. This is easy enough to talk about, but what exactly does this new solid look like? Is...
8 comments
Read more

Do Over: Integration for Over Regions in the Plane

Introduction Earlier in the semester, we visited the topic of integration for over region regions in the plane. This was our first experience with taking integration in the third dimension. To do this, we had to use double integrals to calculate the volume of a region between two surfaces. This topic seems relatively straightforward and anyone who has taken a higher calculus class knows of double integrals. Today, we are going to revisit this topic for a couple of reasons. Why Double Integrals Again? As mentioned before, I am revisiting this topic for a couple of reasons. One of the main reasons is due to how the 3D print turned out. Due to the function, I chose, the final rectangular prism was stand alone. When printing, this resulted in a sloppy prism that lacked structural integrity. The image below is a reference to my original design that includes the prism that had the issue. The main cause of ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Knot Your Average Knot

Knots are an object that we come across in our everyday lives. From tying our shoes to tying a mask around the back of our head, tying and creating knots is something that we begin to become exposed to at a very early age. For our final project for the semester, we decided to go more in-depth into knots and see what information we can get out of our individual knots. To begin, I will show you my knot that I chose to use for this project, and then we will go into all of the interesting information we can pull out of it! My Knot: My knot is a knot with ten crossings, on the atlas you will find it with the name 10 38, which is the number of times you see the strand go beneath itself. Throughout this post, we will go in-depth into a couple of different things we can find out about this particular knot, this list being: finding a way to make it into the unknot, attempting a coloring of the knot, finding the writhe of the knot, and breaking this knot down in...
Post a Comment
Read more